Speakeasies in Indianapolis, Indiana

20 hidden bars found

Indianapolis has quietly cultivated a sophisticated cocktail culture, with mixologists crafting innovative drinks behind unmarked doors and concealed entrances throughout the city. From downtown's historic districts to trendy neighborhoods like Mass Ave and Fountain Square, these hidden establishments offer expertly crafted cocktails in intimate settings that reward the adventurous drinker. Below you'll find 20 of Indianapolis's best-kept secrets, where skilled bartenders and carefully curated atmospheres create memorable drinking experiences away from the crowds.

Mel’s Speakeasy at Commission Row

110 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.8 (48)

Mel's Speakeasy at Commission Row brings hidden bar charm to Indianapolis with an impressive 4.8-star rating from patrons. Located in the Commission Row area, this establishment has earned strong reviews from guests who appreciate its speakeasy atmosphere. The venue offers visitors a chance to experience classic cocktail culture in Indiana's capital city.

intimate craft cocktails upscale cozy +1 more
craft Reservations required
Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge

20 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.6 (1016)

Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge is a highly-regarded cocktail destination in Indianapolis, earning impressive ratings from over 1,000 visitors. This established lounge has built a strong reputation among locals and visitors seeking quality drinks in Indiana's capital city. With its evocative name and stellar reviews, it appears to be a standout venue in Indianapolis's cocktail scene.

speakeasy aesthetic retro/vintage upscale lounge intimate +1 more
classic
1933 Lounge

127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225

4.6 (449)

1933 Lounge brings prohibition-era sophistication to Indianapolis, tucked away above the acclaimed St. Elmo restaurant. This upscale speakeasy serves classic cocktails in a debonair atmosphere that transports guests back to the 1930s. With its refined dress code and elegant ambiance, the lounge has earned a stellar 4.6/5 rating from nearly 450 guests who appreciate its authentic throwback experience.

Located above St. Elmo restaurant
upscale debonair prohibition-era cocktails
$$$ Classic prohibition
Burnside Inn

314 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.6 (316)

Burnside Inn is a highly-regarded hidden bar located in Indianapolis, Indiana, earning an impressive 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 300 reviews. This speakeasy-style establishment has built a strong reputation among locals and visitors alike. The consistently high ratings suggest a quality experience that keeps patrons returning to this Indianapolis gem.

Wiseguy Lounge - Mass Ave

545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.6 (228)

Wiseguy Lounge on Mass Ave is a highly-rated speakeasy-style establishment in Indianapolis, earning an impressive 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 200 reviews. Located in the vibrant Massachusetts Avenue cultural district, this lounge offers guests a sophisticated drinking experience with classic speakeasy ambiance. The consistently high ratings suggest quality cocktails and service that keep patrons returning to this Indianapolis hidden gem.

cocktail lounge seasonal drinks Mass Ave venue pizzeria
craft
Whitaker's Speakeasy Inc

2002 N Arlington Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218

4.6 (115)

Whitaker's Speakeasy Inc operates as a hidden bar in Indianapolis, offering guests an intimate drinking experience away from the typical nightlife scene. This well-regarded establishment has earned strong customer approval with consistently positive reviews. The venue maintains the classic speakeasy tradition of providing a more secluded and refined atmosphere for cocktail enthusiasts in Indiana's capital city.

prohibition era vintage decor sophisticated artisanal cocktails +1 more
craft
Sundry and Vice

850 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.6 (90)

Sundry and Vice is a highly-rated hidden bar in Indianapolis that has earned acclaim from locals and visitors alike. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from 90 reviews, this speakeasy has established itself as a standout destination in the city's cocktail scene. The establishment's intriguing name hints at the classic speakeasy tradition of offering both everyday necessities and indulgent pleasures.

The Inferno Room

902 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203

4.5 (1036)

The Inferno Room is a highly-rated hidden bar located in Indianapolis, Indiana, earning an impressive 4.5 out of 5 stars from over 1,000 reviews. This popular speakeasy-style establishment has built a strong reputation among locals and visitors alike. With such consistently high ratings from a substantial number of patrons, The Inferno Room appears to be a standout destination in Indianapolis's cocktail scene.

Thieves

854 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220

4.5 (182)

Thieves is a highly-rated speakeasy in Indianapolis that has earned strong acclaim from visitors, boasting an impressive 4.5-star rating from 182 reviews. This hidden bar offers patrons an authentic speakeasy experience in the heart of Indiana's capital city. The establishment's reputation suggests a quality cocktail program and atmosphere that keeps guests returning.

The Vault Indy

1542 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46225

4.5 (161)

The Vault Indy transports guests back to the prohibition era with its intimate speakeasy atmosphere and classic cocktails from the 1920s. Located in Indianapolis, this hidden gem requires a secret code at the entrance and features live music performances that enhance its authentic vintage ambiance. With its carefully crafted drinks and atmospheric setting, it has earned strong reviews from visitors seeking a genuine speakeasy experience.

hidden code at entrance
prohibition-era speakeasy craft-cocktails vintage +1 more
$$ classic prohibition Password required
Nowhere Special

608 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.5 (107)

Nowhere Special is a highly-rated hidden bar located in Indianapolis, Indiana that has earned a strong reputation among local patrons. With an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 100 reviews, this speakeasy-style establishment has clearly made its mark on the city's cocktail scene. The venue's understated name hints at the modest charm that draws visitors to this Indianapolis hideaway.

BLIND TIGER

304 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.3 (12)

BLIND TIGER operates as a speakeasy-style establishment in Indianapolis, Indiana. This hidden bar has earned solid reviews from patrons, maintaining a 4.3-star rating across 12 customer evaluations. The venue offers guests an intimate drinking experience in the heart of Indianapolis.

ICON Lounge

148 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

4.1 (227)

ICON Lounge operates as a hidden bar experience in Indianapolis, offering guests an intimate cocktail destination away from the typical nightlife scene. With a solid 4.1-star rating from over 200 reviews, this establishment has built a reputation among locals seeking a more exclusive drinking environment. The venue provides a sophisticated alternative to conventional bars in the Indianapolis area.

Rabbit Hole

47 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

3.8 (39)

Rabbit Hole is a speakeasy-style bar located in Indianapolis, Indiana that offers guests an alternative drinking experience. With a 3.8 out of 5-star rating based on 39 reviews, this establishment has garnered a modest following among local patrons. The venue's name suggests a nod to the classic Alice in Wonderland theme of discovering something unexpected.

The Vault

Bates-Hendricks, Indianapolis, Indiana

The Vault in Indianapolis transports guests back to the Prohibition era through a dramatic four-digit password entry on an authentic vault door. This themed speakeasy specializes in classic prohibition-style cocktails while live jazz performances create an authentic 1920s atmosphere. The bar emphasizes local pairings alongside its carefully crafted vintage cocktail menu.

Four-digit password entered on vault door
themed vault-door live-jazz local-pairings
$$$ Classic prohibition Password required
Commodore

Murphy Building, Fountain Square, Indianapolis, Indiana

Commodore offers a secretive and luxurious atmosphere in Indianapolis, with its hidden entrance located near the Murphy Building. This upscale speakeasy serves specialty cocktails in a dark, intimate setting enhanced by live jazz performances. The venue combines old-world elegance with modern craft cocktails for a truly immersive speakeasy experience.

Hidden entrance near Murphy Building
dark secretive luxe live-jazz
$$$ Specialty cocktails
Verita

Below Bocca, 122 E. 22nd St., Indianapolis, Indiana 46202

Verita is a hidden Italian-inspired speakeasy in Indianapolis, accessible via stairs next to the host stand at Bocca or through a back entrance after 10 p.m. The intimate bar specializes in amaro-focused cocktails, creating a sexy, craft cocktail atmosphere perfect for those seeking a discreet night out. With its Italian flair and secluded setting, Verita offers a sophisticated escape from the typical Indianapolis bar scene.

Stairs next to host stand at Bocca, or back door after 10 p.m.
hidden sexy Italian craft-cocktails
$$$ Italian amaro-focused

Barrel Bar operates as an exclusive underground speakeasy in Indianapolis, with the exact location revealed only upon making a reservation. This intimate subterranean venue specializes in barrel-aged craft cocktails, creating a sophisticated atmosphere for discerning drinkers seeking unique, expertly-aged libations.

Underground location (address provided upon reservation)
intimate underground craft-cocktails exclusive
$$$ Barrel-aged craft Reservations required
Wiseguy Lounge

Mass Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana

Wiseguy Lounge operates without external signage in Indianapolis, hiding in plain sight for those well-dressed patrons who know where to look. This dimly-lit establishment channels prohibition-era atmosphere with leather accents and an elite spirits selection. The bar specializes in bourbon-focused cocktails, creating an upscale speakeasy experience in Indiana's capital.

No external signage; hidden in plain sight
dimly-lit prohibition-era leather elite-spirits
$$$ Bourbon-focused

Bootleggers brings authentic prohibition-era atmosphere to Indianapolis with its password-protected underground entrance, accessible through hints provided at the restaurant upstairs. The speakeasy features gritty, brick-walled interiors that perfectly complement its menu of classic prohibition-style cocktails. This underground hideaway captures the clandestine spirit of the 1920s with its atmospheric setting and expertly crafted vintage drinks.

Password-protected underground entrance; hint available at restaurant upstairs
gritty underground brick-walled classic-cocktails
$$ Classic prohibition Password required